Moody's warns Scotland exit could leave country facing junk rating

Nicola Sturgeon seeking second referendum

Laura Dew
clock • 2 min read

Scotland could see its credit status downgraded to 'junk' if it votes to leave the UK, according to Moody's, as a result of the pressures falling oil prices have placed on its public finances.

Last week, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon called for a second independence referendum to take place before Britain leaves the European Union, saying the country must be offered a choice between a 'hard' Brexit and becoming an independent country.

However, Prime Minister Theresa May rejected the possibility of a second referendum before the term of Britain's divorce from the EU are finalised, saying "now is not the time" for Scotland to leave.

Commenting on the potential for Scotland to become independent, Colin Ellis, chief credit officer for EMEA at Moody's, has warned the country would face "downward pressure" on its finances in the event of independence, according to The Times.

The warning comes as lower oil price, currently sitting at around $55 a barrel, have left Scotland facing a large budget deficit and worse off financially than before the previous referendum in September 2014. 

Back in 2014, when the oil price was above $100, an independent Scotland could have received a rating between A and Baa, placing it within the investment grade bracket.

Sterling falls to two-week low on reports of Scottish referendum

However, Moody's Ellis said current circumstances could see Scotland's rating drop to Ba, a junk status (also known as sub-investment grade), which would place it on a par with Azerbaijan and Guatemala.

Among other implications, this would mean other countries would demand a higher interest rates to lend to Scotland in the future, compared to the stable Aa1 rating currently held by Britain.

Speaking to The Times, Ellis said: "Nobody can predict oil prices but even if you take an optimistic view the fiscal position for Scotland has clearly worsened.

"That means you would be starting from a high fiscal imbalance that the Scottish government would immediately need to address. You would need to raise taxes or cut spending. If not, that would put the normal downward pressures on ratings."

More on Economics

IFS concerned Budget is 'a repeat of the silly games played by the last government'

IFS concerned Budget is 'a repeat of the silly games played by the last government'

More tax rises likely

Linus Uhlig
clock 01 November 2024 • 2 min read
Bank of Japan keeps interest rates unchanged

Bank of Japan keeps interest rates unchanged

Unanimous vote

Sorin-Andrei Dojan
clock 31 October 2024 • 2 min read
Autumn Budget 24: Reeves promises to meet changed fiscal rules by 2030

Autumn Budget 24: Reeves promises to meet changed fiscal rules by 2030

'Public sector net financial liabilities'

Linus Uhlig
clock 30 October 2024 • 3 min read
Trustpilot