When is diversification a hindrance, rather than a help?

Diversification today may require investors to look beyond traditional labels

Hardeep  Tawakley
clock • 2 min read

Partner Insight: A portfolio invested in equities, high yield corporate bonds, convertible debt and real estate may appear on the surface to be diversified, with each asset sounding very different from the other. The reality however is very different.

This is because these securities may have different labels but they exhibit similar relationships to the economic cycle and so are susceptible to delivering negative performance at the same time, rather than providing the offsetting returns one would hope for from true diversification.

But by looking beyond traditional equity/bond labels, it is possible to build a suitably diversified portfolio from the bottom-up according to Investec Diversified Income fund manager John Stopford. 

Portfolio managers Stopford and Jason Borbora aim to achieve defensive returns by actively diversifying the portfolio from the bottom-up. To help achieve this, they divide assets into three groups: Growth, Defensive, and Uncorrelated, separated according to how their returns are impacted by the economic cycle.

According to the team, for the majority of an economic cycle (c.70% by time) Growth assets will provide positive excess returns, compensating investors for the uncertainty of owning assets reliant on economic growth for their returns. According to the managers, this means that investors, on average, should weight their portfolio risk more towards Growth assets while also maintaining at all times a blend of Defensive and Uncorrelated assets. As the cycle mature, the weighting to Defensive and Uncorrelated assets should increase, recognising that the economic growth engine may start to fail. 

This investment approach is just one part of the Investec Diversified Income fund's non-traditional approach to diversification that aims to deliver a defensive' return alongside some capital growth to investors in even the most uncertain of economic environments. They aim to achieve this alongside 'bond-like' volatility. 

Over the past five years, the fund has been able to reduce risk and produce a less concentrated income stream, while maintaining its target yield requirement by using this strategy. 

Click here to read more about Investec Divesrfied Income's approach to diversification, and how the team has delivered an income of between 4%-6% per annum since launch. 

More on Partner Insight

Partner Insight: Mike Riddell on the gilt sell-off - Return of Truss 2.0?

Partner Insight: Mike Riddell on the gilt sell-off - Return of Truss 2.0?

The ongoing global government bond selloff has pushed 30-year gilt yields to their highest level since 1998, drawing comparisons to the fallout from the Truss government’s 2022 budget fiasco. Fidelity Strategic Bond portfolio manager Mike Riddell explores the key factors driving the sharp rise in bond yields and analyses the implications for UK fixed income markets.

Mike Riddell, Portfolio manager, Fidelity Strategic Bond Fund
clock 17 January 2025 • 4 min read
Partner Insight: Quality stocks in a lower interest rate environment

Partner Insight: Quality stocks in a lower interest rate environment

Obe Ejikeme, fund manager at Carmignac, shares insights on how and why quality stocks stand out as a strategic choice in the current economic cycle.

clock 06 January 2025 • 6 min read
Partner Insight: Tech dominance under scrutiny as US inflation eases

Partner Insight: Tech dominance under scrutiny as US inflation eases

Brooks Macdonald
clock 01 November 2024 • 2 min read
Trustpilot